One card advertises 8% back. Another pays 1%. Over a year, the second can leave you with more money. A cashback rate is the start of a calculation, not the end of it, and four questions separate the number on the banner from the number in your balance.
What cashback is
Cashback is a share of your own money coming back. The card provider returns part of what you spent, or part of what you loaded, after the fact.
It is never free money. It is paid out of what the card earns: the fees merchants pay on each payment, the fees you pay yourself, or a marketing budget. That is why it belongs next to the price list, and not in a chapter of its own.
Four questions that decide what it is worth
| Question | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Paid in what? | Dollars, a stablecoin, points or the provider’s own coin. Only the first two have a value you already know. |
| Paid on what? | Every payment, a few categories only, or what you load. Look for what is excluded. |
| On what conditions? | A level to reach, coins to lock up, a monthly subscription or an identity check. |
| Up to how much? | A monthly ceiling, a minimum before you can use it, or a date after which it expires. |
The rate on the banner and the real rate
Take an imaginary card that advertises 5% back, with a ceiling of $25 a month and a subscription of $15 a month. You spend $2,000 with it in a month.
- At 5%, $2,000 would earn $100. The ceiling stops it at $25.
- The subscription takes $15 of that back, which leaves $10.
- $10 on $2,000 is 0.5%: a tenth of the rate on the banner.
Nothing in this example is hidden. Every number was on the offer page. The real rate simply needed all of them.
When the reward is a coin
Many crypto cards pay their rewards in a coin the provider issued itself. Three things then stand between the rate and its value.
- The price moves. A reward earned at one price can be worth half as much, or twice as much, on the day you use it.
- The level has a cost. The highest rates usually ask you to buy and lock up a large amount of the same coin. The rate is earned on your spending, and the risk is carried by your savings.
- Leaving has a price. Turning the coin back into money means a sale, a spread and sometimes a waiting period.
None of this makes a reward in coins a bad deal. It makes it an investment, and it deserves to be judged like one.
Fees first, cashback second
A card with no cashback and no fees beats a card with 2% back and 4% of fees. The number that matters is the net cost: what you pay, minus what really comes back.
Here is that sum for SatoCard, where a top-up costs 3% and 1% of what you load comes back each month.
| Sent in a month | Top-up fee, 3% | Cashback, 1% | Net cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | $15.00 | + $4.85 | $10.15 |
| $2,000 | $60.00 | + $19.40 | $40.60 |
| $10,000 | $300.00 | + $97.00 | $203.00 |
That is about 2% to load the card, with no monthly fee on top. A verified card from an exchange can cost less. It also asks for an identity file, which is a cost of another kind: the comparison of the two sets them side by side.
Does cashback count as income?
It depends on the country, and on the form of the reward. In many places, money returned on what you paid yourself is treated as a discount rather than as income. A reward paid in a coin adds a second question: selling that coin later can create a gain or a loss.
If the amounts matter, ask a local tax adviser. Our guide to spending crypto and taxes covers the general principles.
A checklist before you choose
- Read the unit. Dollars, points or a coin?
- Find the ceiling. Per month, and per year.
- Price the conditions. A subscription and locked coins are part of the cost.
- Subtract the fees. Loading, monthly, conversion and inactivity.
- Do the sum for your own month. Not for the best case on the banner.
How SatoCard answers the four questions
- Paid in what? US dollars, added to your card balance.
- Paid on what? 1% of the dollars that land on your card during the month.
- On what conditions? None: no level, no locked coins, no subscription and no identity check.
- Up to how much? There is no ceiling. It is paid once a month, on the first day of the following month.
The rules are on the cashback page, and the fee calculator shows the cashback under each top-up.
Written by the SatoCard team. This page is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. All guides